About Us

Carol Ann’s is a family business, owned by Debbie Baumgartner, and her husband Jeff. On May 31, 2016, Jeff unexpectedly passed away at the age of 54. He was a devoted husband, a loving father and a proud grandpa.
His wife, children and grandchildren appreciate the out pour of support during this incredibly difficult time.

During the week Jeff opened Carol Ann’s for lunches. For the time being, Carol Ann’s will open daily at 4. The Baumgartner family and staff appreciate the patience and support during these changes.

If we please you, tell others, if we don’t tell us!
Family friendly restaurant – serving pizza, sandwiches kids menu and appetizer
Friday Fish Fries – cod and smelt

2935 Hubertus Rd, Hubertus, Wisconsin

Mon – Thu:
4:00 pm – 8:00 pm
Fri – Sat:
4:00 pm – 9:00 pm
4:00 pm – 8:00 pm


Pizza, salads, sandwiches, kids menu and appetizers
Friday Fish Fries

General Manager
Debbie Baumgartner


Payment Methods

Visa, American Express, Mastercard, Discover and Cash


Call ahead for faster service
Delivery Available on Friday, Saturday and Sunday
Accept reservations, walk-ins welcome
Good For Groups and Kids Take Out and Delivery


Lunch and Dinner

(262) 628-8237

History of Carol Ann’s Pizza, Dick Obremski took over a pizza place at the corner of Hwy 175 and Hubertus Road, in November 1986. Take-out and delivery only was available. About a year later we moved to a sit down restaurant in the strip mall about 2 blocks away. Due to health reasons in March 1992, the pizza place was sold. In September 2011, Caryn Hartfield reopened the pizza place and Debbie Baumgartner took it over in July 2014, so Caryn could take care of her family responsibilities.

Carol Ann’s Pizza was remembered by many, so the name was not changed.

We are serving all fresh vegetables, making dough and baking buns daily, just like Dick would have, if he was still with us!